Marking Consistency

The same answer should get the same mark, whoever marks it.

Admins check markers against calibration examples, draw random samples for a blind second mark, and review marks before release. If you disagree with a mark, a second marker looks again and the higher mark stands.

Step by step

How marks are kept consistent

Part 1 of 6

Calibrate the markers

  1. 1

    Admins keep calibration exemplars and watch for marker drift, which is a marker slowly marking higher or lower than before.

Part 2 of 6

Draw a random sample

  1. 2

    An admin draws a random sample of marked scripts from a series and sends it for a second mark.

Part 3 of 6

A blind second mark

  1. 3

    Another examiner from the same marker pool marks it blind: no first marks, feedback, AI breakdown or first total. The script is anonymous, shown with a candidate number, never a name, email or photo.

Part 4 of 6

Compare with a tolerance

  1. 4

    The totals are compared. The tolerance is the larger of 1 mark and 5% of the paper's marks. Within it, the first mark stands. Outside it, an admin reconciles the two.

Part 5 of 6

Check before release

  1. 5

    A moderation queue lets admins review marks before results are released.

Part 6 of 6

Dispute a mark

  1. 6

    On a marked question or paper, press Dispute mark. Pick a reason or write your own, at least 5 characters. An independent second marker looks again, and the higher of the two marks stands.

How it works

What happens when you dispute a mark

The rules are written into the system.

Disputes

How a dispute is decided

A dispute can only help you. The first and second marks are compared, and the higher of the two stands, with both limited to between 0 and the maximum for the question.

  • Raised: the result says “Higher mark stands — raised from 5 to 7.”
  • Upheld: the result says “Original mark of 5 upheld.”
  • On record: an audit entry is saved when a dispute is raised.
  • Reasons: four quick reasons are offered, or you can write your own.
Blind and anonymous

What the second marker cannot see

A second mark is only worth having if it is independent.

  • No first-marker decisions: no awarded marks, feedback, AI breakdown, exemplary tag, first total or first marker.
  • Automatic marks are shown: keyed questions the platform marked automatically keep their mark, and both totals count them.
  • Anonymous: a candidate number only.
  • Complete: the second mark covers the whole paper, so every question a person marks needs a mark.

What this gives you

Fairness you can check.

Blind

A second marker never sees the first mark.

Anonymous

Scripts carry a candidate number, not a name or photo.

A clear tolerance

1 mark or 5% of the paper's marks, whichever is larger.

Higher mark stands

A dispute cannot lower your mark.

Questions about consistency and disputes

Short answers for students.

Can a dispute lower my mark?+

No. The higher of the first and second marks stands.

Who does the second marking?+

An independent second marker. On a pooled series, that is another examiner from the same marker pool who did not first-mark the script.

What can I write as a reason?+

Pick a quick reason, such as “The mark scheme wasn't applied correctly here.”, or explain in your own words. A reason needs at least 5 characters.

Is every script second-marked?+

No. Admins draw random samples for a second mark, and any dispute you raise is sent to a second marker.

What is the tolerance?+

The larger of 1 mark and 5% of the paper's marks. A series can set its own percentage.

Where do I dispute a mark?+

On your results page, on a marked question or on the whole paper.

Marks you can question, and trust.

Book a Free Demo Explore more features